Buttondown Paid Newsletter & Tier Cost Calculator
Minimalist Markdown-first newsletter billing: check exact Buttondown contact tiers and 0%-cut paid membership savings vs Substack.
adsenseEnabled: true in src/data/monetization.ts.
Buttondown
Standard Plan (0% Member Cut)
$29 /mo
$348/yr bill
beehiiv
Launch (Free) & Scale Plan
$49 /mo
$588/yr bill
Ghost(Pro)
Creator Plan (0% Member Fee)
$95 /mo
$1,140/yr bill
Substack
10% Paid Revenue Share
$120 /mo
$1,440/yr bill
Embed this calculator on Ghost, WordPress, or docs
Pre-loaded with the inputs above. Zero cookies or tracking scripts.
Tier takeaway
At 5,000 total subscribers with 120 paying $10/mo, Buttondown costs a flat $29/month ($348/yr) whereas Substack 10% deducts $120/month ($1,440/yr).
Subscriber tier price curve (1,000 to 100,000 contacts)
Monthly base subscription rates as your email list grows—check steep bracket jumps before migrating.
| Platform | 1,000 | 5,000 | 10,000 | 25,000 | 50,000 | 100,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buttondown | $9/mo | $29/mo | $79/mo | $139/mo | $239/mo | $399/mo |
| Substack +10% paid rev cut | $0/mo | $0/mo | $0/mo | $0/mo | $0/mo | $0/mo |
beehiiv | $0/mo | $49/mo | $79/mo | $119/mo | $199/mo | $299/mo |
| Ghost(Pro) | $31/mo | $95/mo | $149/mo | $249/mo | $399/mo | $649/mo |
Buttondown billing details
Best for: Technical writers, developers, and minimalist newsletter creators wanting Markdown support, API access, and 0% cut on paid subs
Free tier is limited to 100 subscribers; paid tiers charge by contact count but take 0% of paid subscription revenue.
Substack billing details
Best for: Writers starting with zero audience who value Substack app network recommendations
Free if you never charge readers, but once you turn on paid subscriptions, Substack takes 10% forever PLUS ~3.6% + $0.30 Stripe + Billing fees.
beehiiv billing details
Best for: Media brands and paid newsletters scaling via ad network, boosts, and 0% subscription cuts
0% cut on paid memberships (only standard Stripe fees apply), making it thousands cheaper than Substack once paid subs grow.
Ghost(Pro) billing details
Best for: Independent publishers combining an SEO blog CMS + paid member paywalls with 0% revenue cut
0% fee on paid memberships, though custom themes above Starter require the Creator tier.
adsenseEnabled: true in src/data/monetization.ts.
Common questions
What is the cheapest email platform here at 5,000 subscribers?
At 5,000 contacts (120 paid members at $10/mo), Buttondown costs $29.00/month compared to $120.00/month on Substack—saving $1092/year.
Why do some email tools bill for unsubscribed contacts?
Audience-based tools like Mailchimp and Klaviyo count active or unarchived profiles toward your tier bracket, whereas send-volume tools like Brevo store contacts free and bill only for monthly emails sent.
When does Substack 10% become more expensive than beehiiv or Ghost?
Once gross paid subscription revenue crosses ~$490/month (49 subscribers paying $10/mo), Substack's 10% platform fee exceeds a flat $49/month beehiiv Scale subscription—and the gap widens with every new paid reader.

