SaaS Cost Hub
Menu
Subscriber & creator tier model

Buttondown Paid Newsletter & Tier Cost Calculator

Minimalist Markdown-first newsletter billing: check exact Buttondown contact tiers and 0%-cut paid membership savings vs Substack.

Buttondown

Lowest

Standard Plan (0% Member Cut)

$29 /mo

$348/yr bill

Base tier$29/mo
Paid cut (0%)$0/mo
beehiiv logo

beehiiv

Launch (Free) & Scale Plan

$49 /mo

$588/yr bill

Base tier$49/mo
Paid cut (0%)$0/mo

Ghost(Pro)

Creator Plan (0% Member Fee)

$95 /mo

$1,140/yr bill

Base tier$95/mo
Paid cut (0%)$0/mo

Substack

10% Paid Revenue Share

$120 /mo

$1,440/yr bill

Base tier$0/mo
Paid cut (10%)$120/mo
Share scenario
Post on X
S Powered by saascosthub.com Full fee schedule ↗

Tier takeaway

At 5,000 total subscribers with 120 paying $10/mo, Buttondown costs a flat $29/month ($348/yr) whereas Substack 10% deducts $120/month ($1,440/yr).

Subscriber tier price curve (1,000 to 100,000 contacts)

Monthly base subscription rates as your email list grows—check steep bracket jumps before migrating.

Platform 1,000 5,000 10,000 25,000 50,000 100,000
Buttondown
$9/mo $29/mo $79/mo $139/mo $239/mo $399/mo
Substack +10% paid rev cut
$0/mo $0/mo $0/mo $0/mo $0/mo $0/mo
beehiiv logo
beehiiv
$0/mo $49/mo $79/mo $119/mo $199/mo $299/mo
Ghost(Pro)
$31/mo $95/mo $149/mo $249/mo $399/mo $649/mo

Buttondown billing details

Best for: Technical writers, developers, and minimalist newsletter creators wanting Markdown support, API access, and 0% cut on paid subs

Free tier is limited to 100 subscribers; paid tiers charge by contact count but take 0% of paid subscription revenue.

Substack billing details

Best for: Writers starting with zero audience who value Substack app network recommendations

Free if you never charge readers, but once you turn on paid subscriptions, Substack takes 10% forever PLUS ~3.6% + $0.30 Stripe + Billing fees.

beehiiv logo

beehiiv billing details

Best for: Media brands and paid newsletters scaling via ad network, boosts, and 0% subscription cuts

0% cut on paid memberships (only standard Stripe fees apply), making it thousands cheaper than Substack once paid subs grow.

Ghost(Pro) billing details

Best for: Independent publishers combining an SEO blog CMS + paid member paywalls with 0% revenue cut

0% fee on paid memberships, though custom themes above Starter require the Creator tier.

Common questions

What is the cheapest email platform here at 5,000 subscribers?

At 5,000 contacts (120 paid members at $10/mo), Buttondown costs $29.00/month compared to $120.00/month on Substack—saving $1092/year.

Why do some email tools bill for unsubscribed contacts?

Audience-based tools like Mailchimp and Klaviyo count active or unarchived profiles toward your tier bracket, whereas send-volume tools like Brevo store contacts free and bill only for monthly emails sent.

When does Substack 10% become more expensive than beehiiv or Ghost?

Once gross paid subscription revenue crosses ~$490/month (49 subscribers paying $10/mo), Substack's 10% platform fee exceeds a flat $49/month beehiiv Scale subscription—and the gap widens with every new paid reader.