SaaS Cost Hub
Menu
Store break-even model

Etsy Seller Fee & Net Payout Calculator

See every cut Etsy takes on item price and shipping—and compare how much margin you keep by moving repeat buyers to your own store.

Slide or type

Shopify Basic

Lowest

$185.00 /mo

Take-rate: 4.63% · Net $3,815/mo

Plan / hosting$39.00
Card fees$146.00
Gateway / market$0.00

Etsy Standard Seller

$425.00 /mo

Take-rate: 10.63% · Net $3,575/mo

Plan / hosting$0.00
Card fees$145.00
Gateway / market$280.00

Etsy + Offsite Ads (15%)

$1,025.00 /mo

Take-rate: 25.62% · Net $2,975/mo

Plan / hosting$0.00
Card fees$145.00
Gateway / market$880.00
Share scenario
Post on X
S Powered by saascosthub.com Full fee schedule ↗

Break-even summary

Standard Etsy orders lose ~9.5% + $0.45 per item. Once monthly Etsy volume passes $650, a $39 Shopify store charges less in combined platform + card fees.

Total monthly cost across store revenue stages

All-in monthly fees (subscription + card processing at $40 AOV) as monthly GMV scales from $2,500 to $100,000.

Plan $2,500/mo sales$10,000/mo sales$35,000/mo sales$100,000/mo sales
Etsy Standard Seller
$266 (10.63%) $1,063 (10.63%) $3,719 (10.63%) $10,625 (10.63%)
Etsy + Offsite Ads (15%)
$641 (25.63%) $2,563 (25.62%) $8,969 (25.62%) $25,625 (25.62%)
Shopify Basic
$130 (5.22%) $404 (4.04%) $1,317 (3.76%) $3,689 (3.69%)

Common questions

Which option is cheapest at $4,000/month in online sales?

At $4,000/month ($40 average order value), Shopify Basic has the lowest combined subscription + transaction cost at $185.00/month (4.63% effective take-rate), saving $10080/year versus Etsy + Offsite Ads (15%).

Does billing annually change the e-commerce plan break-even point?

Yes. Annual Shopify and BigCommerce plans cut fixed monthly subscription fees by roughly 25%, pulling upgrade break-even thresholds noticeably lower—use the Annual Billing toggle in the calculator above to test exact numbers.

How do third-party payment gateway fees affect store profit?

Using an external gateway on Shopify adds 2.0% on Basic, 1.0% on Grow, and 0.6% on Advanced on top of your card processor fee, whereas WooCommerce and BigCommerce add 0% gateway surcharges.